The public rapporteur recommended during a hearing at the administrative court of Rennes this Friday March 3 2023 to cancel the building permit granted by the mayor of Larmor-Baden to the Giboire group. The latter plans to build a luxury hotel complex on Berder Island.
The building permit granted to the Giboire group for its luxury hotel project on Ile Berder had already been suspended by the administrative court of Rennes on April 12 2022. This hotel complex of more than 8000 m2 is supposed to house 90 rooms with swimming pool and spa.
The project had however officially been abandoned in July 2021 as Michel Giboire announced the day after the partial cancellation of the local urban plan (PLU) of the municipality of Larmor-Baden by the administrative court of Rennes. But this cancellation is not final to date: an appeal has been filed before the Council of State.
Despite their victory in summary proceedings the Federation of environmental protection associations of Morbihan Les Amis des chemins de ronde du Morbihan the association Quality of life in Larmor-Baden and Les Amis du Golfe du Morbihan (AGM ) therefore remain on their guard and have maintained their appeal on the merits against the building permit.
A floor area that would increase by 45%
This Friday 跨際數位行銷有限公司 跨際數位行銷有限公司 March 3 2023 the public rapporteur considered that it was undeniable that there was no village or urbanized sector on the island but only a few buildings in the central part.
Insofar as the floor area will increase by 45% not to mention the parking area of 80 to 100 places the project will therefore generate according to him a very significant change in dimension. It cannot be seen as a simple enlargement but as an extension of urbanization in a particularly little urbanized sector he explained before the administrative court of Rennes.
We invite you to adopt the same protective position of the remarkable spaces that the Nantes administrative court of appeal asked the public rapporteur to the three judges: he recommended the total cancellation of the building permit since it does not seem to him to be regularized without bringing such an upheaval that it would change the very nature of the project.
Me Thomas Dubreuil the lawyer for two applicant associations 跨際數位行銷有限公司 跨際數位行銷有限公司dcard 跨際數位行銷 面試 跨際數位行銷有限公司 for his part noted that the proportion of each construction was very far from a measured envelope: the extensions are for each building systematically higher than the existing building on which they come s lean back. Moreover 跨際數位行銷有限公司 跨際數位行銷有限公司 跨際數位行銷有限公司 he pointed out on the architectural level we are very far from the qualification of architectural integration.
Valuing the existing according to the Giboire group
In the collective imagination it is an island connected by a wood to the mainland with significant afforestation and a Moorish tower from the 19th century the lawyer specializing in environmental law reminded us again This space which must remain coherent.
The lawyer for the municipality of Larmor-Baden has however certified that the disputed building permit does not aim to extend the urbanization on Berder Island: the constructions will simply 跨際數位行銷有限公司 跨際數位行銷 評價 跨際數位行銷 ptt 跨際數位行銷 面試 跨際數位行銷 ptt , 跨際數位行銷 mobile01 , 跨際數位行銷 評價 跨際數位行銷有限公司dcard 跨際數位行銷 面試 跨際數位行銷有限公司 跨際數位行銷有限公司dcard according to her lean against an existing building.
The thesis that the remarkable space must impose itself on the built part of the island is not obvious 跨際數位行銷有限公司 she insisted. The two public rapporteurs who spoke to the administrative court and the administrative court of appeal expressed their hesitations on the fact that the built part is part of the remarkable spaces of the site.
Me Marie-Bénédicte Lusteau the lawyer of the Giboire group presented this project of renovation and reinvestment of the buildings present as a way of enhancing the existing one. It is not a question of transforming the places in a radical way she indicated. According to her the extension will be less than 30% and the influence of the extensions does not impact the wooded area.
The administrative court of Rennes which has put its decision under advisement should render its judgment in about two weeks.
If the building permit were to be declared and this judgment was then confirmed by the Administrative Court of Appeal of Nantes as well as the Council of State then the Giboire group would be entitled to introduce a new complaint against the municipality of Larmor-Baden to be compensated for its various damages.
(With CB/PressPepper), 跨際數位行銷 mobile01 , 跨際數位行銷 ptt , 跨際數位行銷 mobile01 , 跨際數位行銷 評價 跨際數位行銷 面試 跨際數位行銷 評價 , 跨際數位行銷 mobile01 , 跨際數位行銷 ptt 跨際數位行銷 評價